In Defense of Candy Corn
Look, candy corn haters, it's okay. You're allowed to be wrong!
Happy Halloween, ghouls and goblins! Darker Times here with another civil and respectful dispute on the most controversial Halloween candy of all time: candy corn. Let Them Fight is a recurring feature where we have a measured, text-based cage match about a work of art (or candy) we disagree on.
Today is a special post. Instead of getting two of us beefing it out in the digital streets, we’ve got the whole Darker Times team in on the fun.
And spoiler alert: no one on the team hates candy corn.
Aigner: I think I’ve loved candy corn my whole life. It was one of the few seasonal Halloween candies my parents would let me eat. I was raised Muslim, so we didn’t celebrate Halloween or partake in any of the festivities, but candy corn wasn’t decorated in outright Halloween packaging so my parents thought it was okay for me to eat. And eat I did! I ate so much candy corn as a child and still do.
For me it’s the texture and vanilla, honey flavor that crumbles, melts, and then forms this sorta hard sugar wax that again crumbles, melts, and repeats throughout the whole eating process. More than the flavor, it’s the texture, I think that keeps me coming back. How about y’all? Why do you love or like candy corn?
Anna: Well, I only tried candy corn for the first time ever (I think, anyways) for this piece. I really thought I would be coming in here with some hot takes, but ultimately, I liked it. I wouldn’t eat a whole lot of it because it does feel very sweet to me, but I don’t get the hate. It’s a nice treat! I mean, it’s not better than a Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkin, but it’s solid!
Jessica: One thing I’ve learned from raising a couple of kids is that most candy is not supposed to be that good. If it’s too delicious, most kids won’t really like it the same way most kids would be uninterested in a perfect medium-rare steak. If candy is too good it upsets the delicate balance between adults and children. We wouldn’t WANT to give kids the good stuff on Halloween–for free!!–if it’s our very favorite thing. We would want it for ourselves and start handing out something less good instead.
Candy needs to be just the right amount of good. And then nostalgia covers the rest. For me, candy corn is a great example of this. The texture is unique, a little waxy, in a way that my adult self doesn’t exactly find pleasing. But my kid self loved how it was chewy but not sticky, how I could eat it without breaking the rules I was given by the orthodontist. The size is perfect–you can eat just one or a handful, and you can keep going back for more. Both my adult and kid selves like how they just look appropriate for autumn. I don’t have the same love I had as a kid, but if I’m surveying my kids’ candy piles and negotiating for the obligatory candy tax, I wouldn’t be mad at getting candy corn.

Emily: For me, candy corn falls into the same category of seasonal treat as pumpkin spice lattes or marshmallow Peeps or a peppermint mocha. It’s inextricably emotionally tied to a certain time of year, a certain kind of celebration, and I need to have it to feel like I’m really appreciating that season. However—and this is key—I will only eat it once in any given season.
This is nothing against candy corn, really—the older I get, the less tolerance my body has for anything super-sweet, and I’m really overwhelmingly a chocolate girlie, if I’m honest. But making sure I get my candy corn fix once per autumn lets me check that emotional box. It’s like watching Practical Magic before Halloween or Love Actually around Christmas. Is it good for me physically? Oh god no. Is it good for me psychologically? Absolutely.
Aigner: I am definitely not a one bag a year gal. More a one bag a week type. And I am not ashamed to say that I buy the two pound bag or several smaller bags after Halloween once they go on sale. I mean, how could I say no to a $1 bag of candy corn?? It’s just practical and cost effective.
Sometimes I do feel like candy corn puts me in a state where all rational reason leaves my body and all I care about is the next bite. Even if my tummy and taste buds get sick of the flavor and sugar, my mind and tongue cannot get enough of the texture.
I have heard some wild candy corn urban legends and conspiracy theories, like all the bags of candy corn in existence were made all at once and we’re just getting the trickle of candy corn from the warehouse. Which means, one day all the candy corn will be gone. Do y’all have or have y’all heard of any weird candy corn theories or legends?
Anna: WHAT DO YOU MEAN THEY WERE ALL MADE AT ONCE?! I need to know more about this! I guess its waxy-kind-of-texture would lend itself to longevity?
But I have seen the images of candy corn stacked in a circle to resemble corn on the cob. Which I’m not sure is its intended look, but is fascinating all the same. And honestly, the idea of eating candy corn as if it were corn on the cob grosses me out immensely, I’m not sure why, but I’ll see about unpacking that at a later time. Curious to see if anyone else has candy corn legends!

Emily: I have no candy corn legends, but I did see that meme, Anna, which honestly kind of pissed me off because hello???? Each individual piece of candy corn does in fact look like a kernel! Did we all miss that? But that’s neither here nor there. Another question: have any of you ever looked into making homemade candy corn? I know it’s possible, and I’m super curious how different it would taste.
Jessica: I have made a few kinds of candy from scratch back in my church girl days (because what else do you do but cook and bake for your loving family when you are a church girl?) and all my candy-making experiences have taught me one important lesson: buy that shit at the store.
The distinctive texture of candy corn, the way it’s chewy but not sticky, that it isn’t tacky or gummy, is the most important part. And making candy yourself (or getting off-brand versions) is where you lose what makes it most unique. So no, I will not be trying it. Maybe you could make something that looks like candy corn and has a similar flavor? But will I enjoy it without the weird wax of it all? I just can’t see it!
But we do have to acknowledge that candy corn, despite our united enjoyment of it, is one of the most detested form of candy around. It has some very vocal haters! I don’t know that there’s a way to tweak candy corn enough that they would still enjoy it, because they seem to hate basically everything about it. I don’t know that there’s a compromise to be had there.
Aigner: So, the legend has it—as told to me by a local gas station attendant who may or may not have had vampire teeth—is that in the 80s or 70s, when candy corn really hit the American candy stage, Brach’s made billions of these little weird candle-like treats that perplexed people so much that they stopped making them and have since just been selling through what they originally made. Candy corn will be around with the cockroaches after the bombs drop.
Fun candy corn fact: its original name was chicken feed, according to the Wikipedia page I looked at to see when candy corn actually came out. It was the 1880s, y’all. Candy corn is a Halloween candy elder.
I have seen the stack of candy corn looking like corn on the cob! I have two very important thoughts about the candy corn on the cob. It always kinda creeps me out because it looks like a mouth with razor teeth and an endless throat. I like the idea of eating candy corn but not the idea of candy corn eating me.

The other thought I have about the candy cob corn is that I think practically speaking it seems like a choking hazard to eat it like corn on the cob. I mean, candy corn is already a choking hazard—a delicious, waxy choking hazard. It doesn’t need the help of putting a bunch in a row for you to try and gnaw through.
I have considered making home made candy corn before; mainly because I want to make one giant candy corn kernel to rule them all and make me sick. I have never actually done it, though, and I probably won’t. When it comes to Halloween candy, a part of the joy is the magical mystery of candy. If I knew how to make it, I may never eat it again. And that would be a sad Halloween.

Comments ()